Band is one of the most enduring parts of the American school experience, and while some students pick up an instrument in fourth or fifth grade and stay with it all the way through high school, others give it a try in middle school and later. Some students then pivot to sports, theater, or another extracurricular activity. The decision to join school band can shape your child’s school experience, who they hang out with, and even how they view themselves. So how do you know if it’s the right fit? This blog will discuss involvement in school band, its benefits, and when to consider other options.
For information about music lessons in Brooklyn at Williamsburg Music Studio, please get in touch. We’d love to hear from you.
Yes, Your Child Should Do Band in School
The Point Is Not to Be a Pro Musician
Most students who join school band do not go on to become professional performers. That’s not the goal. According to data from the National Endowment for the Arts, only about 1.8% of all U.S. workers are employed in the arts sector, and that includes visual artists, writers, designers, and educators, not just working musicians. Still, nearly every student can benefit from learning an instrument and playing in an ensemble.
A 2018 study from the University of British Columbia found that high school students who participated in music scored higher in math, science, and English, even after controlling for socioeconomic status and prior academic performance. The act of practicing regularly, listening to others, and focusing on detail can help develop cognitive skills that show up in the classroom too.
Band also gives kids a way to express themselves, commit to a shared purpose, and grow through both success and challenge. The point is not to create professionals. It’s to give students a place to grow.
Yes, It’s a Good Extracurricular for College Admissions
Band can be a meaningful part of a student’s college application. It demonstrates commitment over time, teamwork, and personal growth, and these are all things that matter to admissions committees. According to a survey by the National Association for College Admission Counseling, extracurricular involvement is considered “moderately important” by 50% of colleges and universities in shaping admission decisions.
It also matters how a student engages with the activity. Taking on roles like section leader or drum major, participating in regional honors bands, or writing about a memorable concert experience can all add personal depth to a college essay.
Enjoy Incredible Music & Sound Texture
A school band is about discovering a sound that only happens when dozens of musicians play together. There’s no way to replicate the power of a full wind ensemble on your own. Students can experience the thrill of playing Holst’s “First Suite in E-flat,” or the dynamic range of Shostakovich’s “Folk Festival.” They might learn the emotional blend of an Eric Whitacre piece or play melody and counterpoint in a transcription of a Bach chorale.
This level of musical interaction builds listening skills and musical sensitivity. It also gives students exposure to a wide range of styles—from marches and movie scores to classical transcriptions and jazz-inspired arrangements. The feel, sound and experience of sitting amongst dozens of wind instrument players can’t be replicated on Spotify.
Make Friends in a Wholesome Setting
Band is more than music. It’s sectionals after school, last-minute tuning before a concert, group bus rides to regionals, and inside jokes that only your section understands. These shared experiences create an environment where friendships form easily. It’s not uncommon for band kids to build their entire social circles within the program.
A 2020 study originally published in Music Education Research (view here on Sage Research) found that adolescents involved in school ensembles reported higher levels of belonging and social support compared to peers who weren’t part of music programs. For students who feel lost in large schools, band can be an anchor.
Why Shouldn’t You Do Band in School?
If It’s Only a Check Box for College Admissions
There’s a difference between meaningful participation and passive enrollment. If a student joins band simply to pad a college resume, they’re unlikely to benefit from, or enjoy, the experience. Band programs rely on every member showing up ready to contribute. That includes carrying their own weight musically, following the conductor, and supporting the group through every rehearsal and concert.
A student who treats band as a task to check off, rather than something to invest in, may struggle with motivation and engagement. Worse, their lack of interest can pull down the energy of the section or ensemble around them. Colleges look for substance in extracurriculars, not just a long list.
If You Can’t Commit to Practice and Rehearsals
Being in band means being part of a team. That comes with responsibility. Students are expected to practice outside of school, learn their parts, and show up to rehearsals prepared. Concert dates, pep band events, and marching competitions are often non-negotiable.
If your child is already balancing several time-intensive activities—like a club sport, AP classes, or work—it might not be realistic to fit in the commitment that band requires. That doesn’t mean they shouldn’t play music at all, but they may be better off in private lessons or a more flexible ensemble. Every missed rehearsal affects the whole group, and it’s important to respect the time and effort of others.
Final Thoughts
Joining school band can shape your child’s development in surprising ways. It teaches responsibility, collaboration, and self-discipline. It opens up creative possibilities and introduces them to music they might never hear otherwise. It also helps build friendships, often in environments that are more supportive and inclusive than other school settings.At the same time, band is not the right fit for every student. If your child is overcommitted or uninterested in ensemble playing, it’s better to explore other paths. But we believe that music is incredibly important for every student, so whether you want to play a “band instrument” like tuba or flute, or take guitar lessons or learn the piano, we are here to help.
Recent Comments